Phrase guide

carry coals to Newcastle

verb · 1 senses · updated from the 2026-07-25 local source snapshot

Definitions and examples are grouped by meaning. Pronunciation, history, word forms, translations, descendants, synonyms, antonyms, derived terms, and related words appear whenever the source provides them.

Sound

Pronunciation

Each Play button uses your device's default local English voice, or a natural local fallback. The selected voice name appears after playback. This is synthesized speech, not a source recording.

  • Australia: Recorded audio is listed in the source snapshot.

1

verb

Meaning 1

To do something that is unneeded or redundant.

Definition source: English Wiktionary via Wiktextract

Usage: idiomatic

No example sentence was provided for this meaning.

Meaning relationships

Synonyms: bring owls to Athens, bring sand to the beach, sell ice to Eskimos

Antonyms: none provided

History

Etymology

Newcastle upon Tyne (in England) was a major coal-exporting city, so sending coal there would be pointless.

Across languages

Translations

46 source translations are retained for this English entry.

  • Asturian: llevar fierro a Bilbao — do something unneeded or redundant
  • Catalan: portar aigua al mar — do something unneeded or redundant
  • Chinese Mandarin: 多此一舉 /多此一举 (duōcǐyījǔ) — do something unneeded or redundant
  • Chinese Mandarin: 脫褲子放屁 /脱裤子放屁 (tuō khùzi fàngpì) — do something unneeded or redundant
  • Czech: nosit dříví do lesa — do something unneeded or redundant
  • Czech: nosit sovy do Atén — do something unneeded or redundant
  • Danish: give bagerbørn hvedebrød — do something unneeded or redundant
  • Dutch: uilen naar Athene dragen — do something unneeded or redundant
  • Dutch: water naar de zee dragen — do something unneeded or redundant
  • Esperanto: porti akvon al rivero — do something unneeded or redundant
  • Esperanto: porti strigojn al Ateno — do something unneeded or redundant
  • Estonian: kilplasetööd tegema — do something unneeded or redundant
  • Finnish: kantaa vettä kaivoon — do something unneeded or redundant
  • French: porter de l'eau à la rivière — do something unneeded or redundant
  • German: Eulen nach Athen tragen — do something unneeded or redundant
  • German: Holz in den Wald tragen — do something unneeded or redundant
  • German: Wasser ins Meer tragen — do something unneeded or redundant
  • Ancient Greek: γλαῦκ’ εἰς Ἀθήνας (glaûk’ eis Athḗnas) — do something unneeded or redundant
  • Hungarian: vizet hord a Dunába — do something unneeded or redundant
  • Icelandic: bera í bakkafullan lækinn — do something unneeded or redundant
  • Irish: beir liúdar go Toraigh — do something unneeded or redundant
  • Irish: cuimil saille ar thóin na muice méithe — do something unneeded or redundant
  • Italian: portare nottole ad Atene — do something unneeded or redundant
  • Italian: portare civette ad Atene — do something unneeded or redundant
  • Italian: portare vasi a Samo — do something unneeded or redundant
  • Japanese: 無駄骨を折る (mudabone wo oru) — do something unneeded or redundant
  • Latin: in silvam ligna ferō — do something unneeded or redundant
  • Norwegian Bokmål: gi bakerens barn brød — do something unneeded or redundant
  • Norwegian Bokmål: gå over bekken etter vann — do something unneeded or redundant
  • Norwegian Nynorsk: gje brød til bakaren sine born — do something unneeded or redundant
  • Polish: wozić drewno do lasu — do something unneeded or redundant
  • Portuguese: levar água ao mar — do something unneeded or redundant
  • Portuguese: chover no molhado — do something unneeded or redundant
  • Scottish Gaelic: thoir fiodhrach do Loch Abar — do something unneeded or redundant
  • Scottish Gaelic: thoir eich a dh'Innse Gall — do something unneeded or redundant
  • Slovak: voziť drevo do hory — do something unneeded or redundant
  • Slovak: nosiť sovy do Atén — do something unneeded or redundant
  • Slovene: zlivati vodo v morje — do something unneeded or redundant
  • Spanish: llevar leña al monte — do something unneeded or redundant
  • Spanish: llevar hierro a Vizcaya — do something unneeded or redundant
  • Swedish: bära ugglor till Aten — do something unneeded or redundant
  • Turkish: denize su götürmek — do something unneeded or redundant
  • Vietnamese: chở củi về rừng — do something unneeded or redundant
  • Vietnamese: dã tràng xe cát biển Đông — do something unneeded or redundant
  • Vietnamese: dã tràng xe cát — do something unneeded or redundant
  • Welsh: cario glo i Fflint — do something unneeded or redundant